Nov 28th, 2023

Cornelius Man Accused of 2022 Manslaughter Acquitted on All Charges

A notable legal development occurred in the Washington County Circuit Court, where a 46-year-old Cornelius man was acquitted of charges related to a shooting incident that occurred in March 2022. The individual had faced serious allegations, including first-degree manslaughter and unlawful use of a weapon, in the death of a 63-year-old man.

The Trial Process and Verdict

Initiated on November 7, after a delay from its original May schedule, the trial was conducted as a bench trial upon the defendant’s request. This format meant that the judge, rather than a jury, was responsible for the final decision. The presiding judge delivered the verdict of acquittal on November 20, thereby avoiding a mandatory minimum sentence of 10 years, which would have applied in case of a manslaughter conviction.

The Meaning of Acquittal

It is crucial to understand that an acquittal does not imply innocence. Rather, it indicates that the prosecution was not able to prove the defendant’s guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. This principle is a cornerstone of the judicial system, ensuring that convictions are based on solid and conclusive evidence.

The Incident and Defense

The incident in question reportedly stemmed from an earlier verbal dispute between the two men. The situation escalated when the deceased, recognizing the defendant’s vehicle, confronted him at his own residence. The deceased refused to leave the property after being told numerous times to leave. The deceased attempted to take the shotgun from the homeowner. A struggle then ensued over the gun. Criminal Law Attorneys Jason Short and Tucker Rosetto successfully argued that the homeowner was in his right to defend himself but the gun accidentally discharged during this struggle.

The Result of the Struggle

As Salem Criminal Defense Attorney Jason Short emphasized, evidence suggesting that the safety of the shotgun was disengaged during the struggle initiated by the deceased, leading to its accidental discharge. Subsequently, the injured man was taken to Legacy Emmanual Medical Center, where he passed away without providing a statement to law enforcement.

Case Closed

With the acquittal, the case has been officially closed in the Washington County Circuit Court. This case highlights the complexities and nuances of legal proceedings, especially in matters involving serious charges such as manslaughter. It also underscores the importance of a thorough and fair legal process, where every individual is given the opportunity to present their case and be judged based on the evidence.

Read more about this case here: